How to Validate AlphaFold Structures

1 minute read

AlphaFold has revolutionized protein structure prediction, but validating its output is essential before using the model in downstream applications like docking or molecular dynamics. Here’s a step-by-step guide to assess the quality and reliability of AlphaFold-predicted structures.

🧬 How to Validate AlphaFold Structures

πŸ” 1. Check Prediction Confidence

AlphaFold provides two key metrics:

  • pLDDT (per-residue confidence):
    • 90: Very high confidence

    • 70–90: Confident
    • <70: Low confidence (often in loops or disordered regions)
  • PAE (Predicted Aligned Error):
    • Lower is better.
    • Useful to assess domain-level flexibility or uncertainty in multi-domain proteins.

πŸ“Œ Tip: You can visualize both scores in the AlphaFold DB or with tools like PyMOL or ChimeraX.


🧫 2. Visual Inspection

Use molecular visualization tools to manually inspect the structure:

  • PyMOL
  • UCSF Chimera / ChimeraX
  • Mol* (web-based viewer)

Look for:

  • Disordered loops
  • Steric clashes
  • Abnormal bond angles
  • Missing secondary structure elements

πŸ§ͺ 3. Structure Quality Assessment Tools

You can evaluate the stereochemistry and structural quality using these tools:

ToolPurpose
MolProbityClash score, Ramachandran outliers
PROCHECKGeometry, dihedrals
WHAT_CHECKStereochemical checks
SwissModel Structure AssessmentQMEAN Z-score
Verify3DEnvironment profile check
ERRATNon-bonded interaction analysis

πŸ“¦ Most of these tools accept PDB files and provide web or local versions.


πŸ”¬ 4. Compare with Experimental Structures

If homologous structures exist:

  • Align the AlphaFold model with known crystal/NMR structures using TM-align, PyMOL, or Chimera.
  • Compute RMSD to assess structural similarity.

βš™οΈ 5. Functional and Dynamic Validation

  • Dock known ligands to check active/binding site geometry.
  • Perform Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations to test structure stability over time.
    • Use GROMACS, AMBER, or NAMD.

βœ… Summary

Validation StepWhy It Matters
pLDDT/PAE ScoresConfidence in prediction
Visual InspectionCatch obvious errors
Geometry ToolsCheck stereochemical quality
Structural ComparisonCross-validate with known structures
Functional TestsAssess biological relevance

πŸ“š References

  • Jumper et al., Nature (2021): AlphaFold paper
  • AlphaFold Protein Structure Database: https://alphafold.ebi.ac.uk/
  • MolProbity: http://molprobity.biochem.duke.edu/